Hey all! I need to tell you more about the limited decks I’m making these days. they are taking a lot of my personal projects time, and I like it! I told you last time that I finished my first two decks, well guess what I haven’t had the time to play test them yet! I started designing a couple more though, which I will be showcasing in the near future. What I want to talk about today is commons. And since I’ve created two decks containing green cards, I will be telling you about the fundamental green cards, that I will call veggies, because they are fun-da-men-tal to a healthy Magic deck.
As you might know, even though rares and uncommon are splashy and powerful, in limited draft as much as in general design, the most important are your commons, simply because they are going to make the most of your deck and experience. In a booster they are respectively 14 and 4.6 times more frequent than rares and uncommons. Commons are hard to design because at the end of the day you can’t make all of them too exciting or complicated if you want to mellow out the power level and not create what designers call “power creep”, which means cards become more and more powerful as time and new editions pass by. So what kind of good but not too good greens have I created so far?
Now I believe deathtouch might be too good an upside to staple to a regular 2/2. Deathtouch is enabling you to defend yourself against huge monsters after all. So how about a 2/1? Sounds more like it to me. At the end of the day, this creates a creature that will basically trade against ANY other one in a fight, and losing your creatures most of the time isn’t usually what you want in green, so the power level should be in check here.
Since I wanted to make it mostly less good than Rampant Growth, I decided to try and make it cost more for every creature you had played already. After all, you are supposed to need this kind of spell early in the game. But since I didn’t want the spell to be strictly worse, I added some minor life gain to it, which could actually make it pretty good in long games. So what do you think, is the power level under control for this one?
Volarian Gargantua. This one is perfect to rest our brains a little. In green we need what we call “beef”, big bad creatures to hurt your opponent. A 5/4 does that pretty well, especially in limited, and 5 isn’t a bad price for it. That being said it’s not overly powerful and definitely not a complex card, so common should be a perfect place for it.
Knowing how green gets access to big creatures easily, we could make a case to have it cost only 1 green mana and 4 colorless (and call it Spined Wurm), but that’s really not a game changer at 5 total cost. Classic.
Scornful Earthmage. 180 degrees on that one, it is actually pretty complicated. For that alone you might want to make it uncommon. What we have here is a 2/1 for three, which isn’t good. But he can also will send a land back to our opponent’s hand, and that my friends, is very powerful.
I limited Earthmage’s ability to tapped lands, which means the opponent will have already used their lands, and also that you might send your own lands to your hand if you don’t have a choice.
I will need testing on this one, I don’t how good he is just yet.
Soul of Volaria. Now we are back in the realm of simple cards. You should know that in limited (if you’re new here, look it up) a 3/3 for 4 is a solid creature, if not exciting.
I’m not sure where I found the idea for this card, but I know I wanted its upside to be hard to trigger, to keep its efficiency under wraps. In limited it’s fairly hard to keep 4 creatures alive, and if you get there you are probably winning or playing on a stuck board state. I’m afraid the upside once attained is still too strong though, but more testing will tell us for sure. Keep an eye on that guy.
Keratha Tamer is our last guest in this episode. The “Vanilla Test” tells us that this card, a virtual 3/3 for 3, is pretty good. It’s arguable whether it being on two creatures is better or worse, though I would say in a competition for power and big creatures you would rather have a 3/3 than a 1/1 and a 2/2.
Here at Bullzzai, we’re making it a great deal by adding vigilance on the 1/1! It’s not all that much really, but it’s a nice little throw-in to make Keratha Tamer an interesting card, yet not too powerful. Just how we like it 🙂
As you can see, it is definitely a great task to balance power at common rarity. It takes a great sense of card evaluation if you want to be able to push them to be good or even great cards, without making them broken, or even giving them attributes that would make them better rares. I haven’t reached that master state, but definitely working on it 🙂
Now I have to keep training hard and show you more non-creatures spells. Let’s agree we’ll look at those next time. Until then have a great week!